Page 45 - ACTL_Sum23

petition for habeas corpus and trooped to Guantánamo to meet with their clients. Twenty-two years later, we are still, gradually, whittling the number of men held with no charge or trial. Twen- ty-five men were left as he spoke to us in February, 2023. The die is cast on Guantánamo, he says. We know what it is. We don’t know everything about it yet. But we will. And Professor Margulies warned us that a Guantánamo could happen again. We don’t know when or how or what shape it will take, but history tells us that there will be another. Professor Margulies theorizes it might have something to do with global migration induced by climate change. A band of the planet home to a billion people will over the next forty or fifty years become uninhabitable. Where do you think those people will go? They will come north. Our world will change and with change will come fear and with fear will come an impetus to respond to this new danger. Professor Margulies urged us to be alert to the sounds and signs as the next Guantánamo approaches. The first thing you will hear is “this time is different.” Yes, Guantánamo was a mistake, the time before was a mistake, and the one before that. But this time is different. Accustom yourself to be alert to these phrases: We have nev- er. We have never encountered, we have never faced, we have never been threatened. That’s what you’ll hear. That’s the sign that something is rumbling down the street toward you. And the next thing you will hear is the language of urgency and danger. We have never faced this and now it is urgent, it is desperately urgent. Remember 2001, remember the language that Osama bin Laden had suitcase nukes; that the anthrax scare was Al-Qaeda; that dirty bombs would be detonated in stadiums. Wise people with serious degrees and letters after their names and prominent positions were telling us that now is the time to act. We’ve never faced this before and the time to act is now. And the last thing you’ll hear is that our institutions are not fit for this challenge. Our institutions cannot handle this challenge. And most of all, the law cannot handle this chal- lenge. The law will impede what we need to do and what we need to do urgently. That’s what you will hear. But these three triggers alone are not enough to create the next Guantánamo. For that, you need the sound of demo- nization. You need to be told that “they” are not like us; that they do not deserve the protections, the dignity, and the respect that humans deserve. With those three triggers and then demonization, the time is ripe for imprisonment without trial. Professor Margulies called on the College to be vigilant. John Chandler Atlanta, GA SUMMER 2023 JOURNAL 44 “When you hear those words, it will be time for the College to do what it has done so masterfully for the last twenty years. It will be time for you to stand next to a person who has been cast out, to stand next to the person who the whole world believes is a monster, and to say the fourteen words, to say the one sentence that renders this and every Guantánamo impossible. It will be time for us to say: ‘There is no them, there is only us, and this person is going home.’”